Homemade Mayonnaise

Encouraged by our recent experiments with butter and mozzarella, we decided to make some homemade mayonnaise. I’ve never been a huge fan of mayonnaise, but I’ve been enjoying it a little more than I used to. I’ve mixed all kinds of ingredients with it to balance out various sandwiches and burgers, and I started wondering if I’d like mayonnaise more if I could adjust the flavor, as was suggested in this Bon Appetit column. Well, we rolled up our sleeves and decided to try our hand at making a better mayonnaise than Mr. Hellman and Mrs. Duke. We based our recipe on this one, but dialed down the mustard and vinegar a bit.


Believe it or not, this is everything you need.

Here’s the lemon juice, egg, mustard and vinegar mixture before the oil is added:


Here’s the mixture after 1/4 cup of oil is added. It’s still a little yellow, but it’s starting to look like mayonnaise:


My arm got exhausted after stirring the whisk for about five minutes, so my wife stepped in to stir while I drizzled in the last 1/4 cup of oil. She’s moving so fast that the picture is just a blur:


Here’s the finished product. You can see that the color faded a little after all of the oil was incorporated:


It’s obviously going to taste good on a sandwich where it’s just a minor flavor, but we wondered if it would it be good as a star of the show. So I decided to make a new potato salad based loosely on this recipe.

If necessity is the mother of all invention, then inventory is the father of creative dishes. We didn’t have everything in that recipe, so we mixed our homemade mayonnaise with a little sour cream, heavy whipping cream, white wine and herbs from the garden (chives, dill and a little parsley), and used it to dress some steamed new potatoes and asparagus spears:


We chilled it all for a while, and it came out really good:

100_2025remodeling our kitchen, so we made large dishes of broccoli/cheese/rice/chicken casserole, hash brown casserole and spaghetti and meatballs. Out of all those great comfort foods, this potato salad was our favorite meal. Next time I’ll mince some capers to get that briny taste that pickles usually bring to potato salad, chop up some red onion for added flavor and texture, and use champagne instead of white wine to flavor the mayonnaise mixture. That should round the dish out perfectly.

If we make mayonnaise again, I’ll do it in the stand mixer or food processor. Still, even with the manual stirring, this mayonnaise was easy to make and we couldn’t be happier with the results. Maybe next time we have guests over I’ll jazz it up with some garlic and herbs and call it aioli. That’s what so many restaurants are starting to do these days.

Homemade Mayonnaise
Tagged on:                     

9 thoughts on “Homemade Mayonnaise

  • May 15, 2009 at 10:03 am

    Chad I have just found your site and have fallen in love with the many tips you write about. I run a link called ‘Buddy’s Friday’ on my blog http://margarets-ramblings.blogspot.com/ and wondered if you would like to link this post to it with the Mr Linky on my blog. ‘Buddy’y Friday’ is all about showing others that there are other and cheaper ways of living well in the current cash climate. I found it hard to chose which of your posts to ask you about as there are so many great ones. I do hope you will join us,


  • December 22, 2009 at 5:54 pm

    I’m trying to teach my husband to cook, he doesn’t want to. :) Do you think this is a good idea?

  • Pingback: Homemade Linguine Noodles

  • Pingback: Authentic Spaghetti Alla Carbonara

  • Pingback: Creamy Pimento Cheese Recipe

  • Pingback: Homemade Sweet Potato Chips & Garlic Aioli

  • Pingback: Potato & Asparagus Salad

  • April 6, 2013 at 11:53 pm

    Have you tried making this with an immersion blender? SO, SO much easier. Love your blog, btw! Great recipes – I’ve tried your version of the no-knead bread and really liked it. Perfect tweaks.

    • April 8, 2013 at 7:48 am

      I’m always wondering if I should get an immersion blender, but I already have too many gadgets piled up in my kitchen. I usually use my food processor or stand mixer to make mayo/aioli these days. An immersion blender would cut down on a lot of the cleaning. Thanks for dropping by!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *